I set my duffel bag by the door, and I took off my coat, and I sat down on the sofa, across from him, and I folded my hands in my lap, and I waited. David did not sit. He stayed by the fireplace, staring at the floor, and I could see that his hands were shaking.
Gregory began to talk, and as he talked, the whole story came out, piece by piece, the way a good story does, until I could see the shape of it clearly for the first time.
He told me that David had been working for months to win the director’s position, and that part of his pitch, the part he had made in meetings and in emails and over drinks after work, was that he was a man of substance, a man who owned a beautiful home, a man who had built something solid and lasting. Gregory, who was careful with his company’s money and careful with the people he promoted, had decided to check. It was not personal, he said. It was business. Before you hand a man a director’s title and a budget of millions of dollars, you find out whether the man is who he says he is.
So Gregory had his assistant pull the county property records, and what he found was that the house on Alder Lane was not David’s at all. The deed was in one name only, and that name was Nora Vale. The mortgage, what little remained of it, was in her name. The tax records were in her name. David’s name appeared nowhere, not on a single document connected to the house, and Gregory told me, very quietly, that he had found this interesting, but not damning. A man could love a house his wife owned. That was no crime. So he came to dinner on Christmas Eve, he said, with an open mind, ready to meet the woman who had built such a home, ready to offer David the promotion if the evening went well.
But when he arrived, I was not there. David told him I was visiting family, that I sent my regards, that I would be sorry to have missed him. Gregory said he accepted this at first, because it was Christmas Eve, and people have families, and he did not think much of it. But as the evening went on, he began to notice things. David talked about the house as if he had built it himself. He pointed out the new pine floors and said, “I laid those myself,” when in fact my father and I had laid them, on our knees, over three long weekends. He showed Gregory the roof and said, “I replaced that two years ago,” when in fact my father and I had replaced it, one shingle at a time. He poured the wine and said, “This is my home, Gregory. Everything you see here, I built it.” And Gregory, who had spent the afternoon reading the county records, sat in my dining room and listened to a man take credit for a woman’s life’s work, and he began to feel, as he put it, “uncomfortable in a way I have rarely felt in business.”
Then, Gregory said, came the moment that changed everything. After dinner, over coffee in the living room, David had shown him a folder. He had said, “I want you to see something, Gregory, so you know what kind of man I am.” Inside the folder was a document, a home equity agreement, and at the bottom of it were two signatures: David’s, and mine. Or what was supposed to be mine. Gregory looked at the signature, and then he looked at David, and he asked a simple question: “Did your wife sign this?”
David said yes. He said it quickly, too quickly, and Gregory, who had spent thirty years reading people in negotiations, knew at once that it was a lie. He told me that he did not confront David that night. He finished his coffee. He thanked him for dinner. He went home, and he called his lawyer, and he asked his lawyer to compare the signature on that document with my signature on the county records, the signature I had written when I bought the house all those years ago. And his lawyer called him back this morning, Christmas morning, and told him what he already suspected: the signatures did not match. The signature on David’s document was a forgery. Someone had practiced my handwriting and signed my name to a document that would have let David borrow against my house, and that someone was sitting in this room.
The living room was silent when Gregory finished. The only sound was the ticking of the clock on the mantel, the one my father had given me, and the soft hiss of the radiator. David was still staring at the floor, and his face had gone from gray to white, and I could see the sweat on his forehead, even though the room was not warm.